My daughter's ex-laptop was a (pink!) Dell inspiron with the infamous Broadband BCM4312 network controller. It was quirky in many other respects too (or words to that effect). I think that I had to reinstall Mint about three times due to various problems. At one point she couldn't minimize windows at all as they would just disappear and couldn't be recovered. There were a number of posts referring to this bug on the Ubuntu forum.
After the initial shock of an iconless desktop and keybindings, she is now quite happy using my samsung nc10 with #!cb 9.04. I fear that it may not be returned to its rightful owner without a struggle. She's is replacing the Dell with an Acer Veriton n260g nettop at the end of the month. I have been using one for ten months and it is a snappy and linux-friendly machine.
I don't really want to reinstall cb10 again for my daughter in two or three months time which is why I thought I would stick with 9.04 for the moment. She just wants a stable, fully functioning system without dad having to constantly troubleshoot or reinstall.
After my experiences with the pink Dell laptop-from-hell I can understand why in some cases Macs are a good choice of computer. Linux in this case failed miserably to deliver a reasonable desktop experience and would put off any potential converts. Who cares if the computer boots in 20 seconds if in fact you can't get it to function stably or with wireless. Perhaps Ubuntu should try and address the problem of drivers for certain combinations of hardware, otherwise punters are going to go elsewhere. End of rant!
Perhaps I'll reconsider how to proceed after I have tried Statler on my main computer (Acer veriton n260g). Time for thought, I suppose.
"In spite of the cost of living, it's still popular."
Kathleen Norris